Feature Article

Click for Home

The Future of Glaucoma in Asia (continued)

Racial Variations in Angle Closure Glaucoma

It is becoming clear that racial differences in angle configurations play a role in the pathogenesis of PACG.4 The prevalence of this disease in East Asians is approximately 1% and accounts for 50% of all glaucomas in this population. PACG is therefore probably the most widespread type of glaucoma worldwide because of the large population in East Asia.22,23

The underlying mechanism for the high incidence of angle closure glaucoma among Asians and blacks compared with Caucasians is not clear.24 However, the thickness and rigidity of the iris in these groups have been postulated as possible causes. Oh et al found that the iris joined the ciliary body more anteriorly in Asians than in blacks or Caucasians (p = 0.03) [Table 4], which may predispose to progressive formation of PAS.24 In addition, the irides of Asians had a greater tendency to a concave figuration of the peripheral iris compared with the other 2 groups (Table 5). These authors sug-gested that there may be a direct relationship between the anatomical configuration of the anterior chamber angle, particularly the position of iris insertion, and the comparatively high rate of angle closure glaucoma among Asians.

Table 4. Position of iris insertion after indentation gonioscopy in different racial groups.

Position
Position Caucasian (n = 100) No.
African-American (n = 97) No. Asian (n = 94) No.

At trabecular meshwork

0

0

0

At scleral spur

10

17

25

At anterior ciliary bodyAt anterior ciliary body

80

68

65
At mid ciliary body 10

11

4

Table 5. Peripheral curvature of the iris in different racial groups.

Curvature
Caucasian (n = 100) No.
African-American (n = 97) Asian (n = 94)

Steep anterior bowing

2

1

0

Regular

96

91

82

Concave

2

5

12

Glaucoma is a major cause of blindness in India.25 Indeed, 12.8% of the 8.9 million blind people in India are blind due to glaucoma, and angle closure glaucoma con-stitutes 45.9% of all primary adult glaucomas.26 The Vellore Eye Survey, performed in southern India, found that PACG was significantly more common than primary open angle glaucoma (POAG), with a prevalence of 43.2 for PACG and 4.1 for POAG per 1,000 population, respectively.25 However, the reason for this high rate is probably due to the case definition used for this study.

Dandona et al performed an assessment of the prevalence and features of angle closure glaucoma in an urban population in South India.27 Among people aged 40 years or older, 1.08% had manifest PACG and 2.21% had occludable angles, which is substantially less than that reported in Mongolia. Interestingly, only one-third of patients with PACG had been previously diagnosed, and 41.7% were blind in one or both eyes due to PACG. Projecting these results to the estimated 288 million urban population in India suggests that 2.4 million people in urban India may have PACG or are at risk for the disease due to the presence of occludable angles.

A survey of visual morbidity in Mongolia found that 35% of the blindness in the population aged 40 years or older was due to glaucoma, and was similar to that due to cataract (36%).28 A study to classify glaucoma according to mechanism among 942 individuals in Mongolia found that the prevalence of PACG was 1.4% and that of gonioscopically occludable angles was 6.4%, while the prevalence of POAG was only 0.5%.

A Singapore study found a higher rate of hospital admissions for PACG among Chinese in Singapore than for Malays or Indians (Table 6).29 The rates did not differ significantly between Malays and Indians in this study, and were similar to those seen in Thailand, another ethnic Southeast Asian population. Meanwhile, Nguyen et al found that Vietnamese people living in the USA had a higher prevalence of narrow angles and a greater risk of angle closure than Caucasians.30

Table 6. Mean annual admission rate for primary angle closure glaucoma per 100,000 population for different ethnic groups in Singapore between 1993 and 1997.

Race Rate per 100,000 Confidence interval

Chinese

12.2

10.5, 13.7

Malay

6.0

4.9, 7.3

Indian

6.3

5.1, 7.6

These studies are of particular interest since Mongolia is believed to be the genetic centre of the Sino-Mongoloid race, with migration occurring among the neighbouring regions of North and East Asia, and to Alaska, Canada, and Greenland.31 The disparity in prevalence of PACG between the Inuit populations and Caucasians has been attributed to the shallow anterior chamber found among the Inuit,31 which is also seen among the East Asian populations.24

 

Conclusion

In the 1998 Dohlman Lecture, Spaeth described glaucoma as a process in which there are stages of deterioration, the final stage being total blindness and incapacitation due to loss of visual function. This hypothesis led to the premise that glaucoma is a process or group of processes characterised by progressive damage to ocular tissues.32 In describing the problems of defining glaucoma, Spaeth questioned whether there is any one thing that applies to everybody with glaucoma and noted that not all patients pass through every stage of glaucoma a sudden rise in IOP may cause damage to many different tissues in the eye, while a slow increase in IOP may only damage the optic nerve and its connections. Therefore, rather than defining glaucoma, Spaeth set out a series of stages from objective and subjective normality through symptomatic damage to incapacitation (Table 7).

Table 7. Stages of glaucoma according toSpaeth.

Glaucoma suspect
Positive family history
    Angle closure attack
    Visual loss due to chronic glaucoma
Intraocular pressure 21 mm Hg
Occludable anterior chamber angle
Suspicious optic nerve damage
Suspicious visual loss
Risk factors
    Race
    Myopia
    Obesity
        Systemic hypotension
        Nutritional deficiency
___________________________________________________
Asymptomatic damage
(glaucoma condition)
Questionable damage
    Intraocular pressure 30 mm Hg to 40 mm Hg
    Questionable unexplained disc asymmetry without specific glaucoma findings
    Non-specific field changes
Definite damage
    Intraocular pressure 40 mm Hg to 50 mm Hg
    Disc changes
        Acquired pit of the optic nerve
        Localised pallor with thinning of rim to a disc/rim ratio of < 0.1
        Disc haemorrhage
    Visual field
        Definite reproducible nasal step
        Paracentral defect
        Arcuate scotoma
Marked damage change in the optic disc or visual field that would be expected to cause symptoms, rim thickness < 0.1 or bilateral dense visual field loss
___________________________________________________
Symptomatic damage
Questionable functional loss
Mild to moderate functional loss able to perform most tasks but aware of limitations
Severe functional limitation aware of marked change in lifestyle required because of poor visual function
Incapacitation unable to manage self care

From a practical point of view, this can be helpful in treating patients on the basis of what is happening to that individual, rather than on the basis of comparison to the 'normal' population.

 

Previous PageReferences

 

Set the Agenda for Your Journal

As practising ophthalmologists in the Asia-Pacific region, Asian Journal of OPHTHALMOLOGY is your Journal. Asian Journal of OPHTHALMOLOGY is intended to be a vehicle for the exchange of information relevant to clinical practice in Asia. Make the Journal work for you by sending your letters, contributions, articles, meeting reports and announcements, and any other information that may interest your colleagues. By telling us what you would like to see published in Asian Journal of OPHTHALMOLOGY, you can make this truly your Journal.

Please send your contributions to:

The Editor
Asian Journal of OPHTHALMOLOGY
Scientific Communications (Hong Kong) Ltd
4/F, 11 Queen Victoria Street
Central
Hong Kong

Tel:
Fax:
Email:

Download the complete article here:    feature.pdf

To view the file requires Acrobat Reader ® which is distributed freely here.

Click here to get Adobe Acrobat Reader


Home - Table of Contents - Current Issue - Back Issues -
Congress Calendar
- Editorial Board
- - Free Subscription